# Bay beats Island 71.5 to 66.0 on the published weights

HEAD TO HEAD, read 13 Nov 2026

**The short answer.** Bay scores 71.5 of 100 against Island at 66.0 on the published weights. Bay leads on Deployment (9 to 6), Sees (8 to 7) and Stops (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Transparency (3 to 1), Beyond (8 to 7) and Policy (7 to 6). By situation, Bay leads in all five.

## Verdict on the published weights

Bay scores 71.5 of 100 and Island scores 66.0. Bay is ahead on 3 of 7 criteria and behind on 3; 1 is level. Bay leads on Deployment (9 to 6), Sees (8 to 7) and Stops (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Transparency (3 to 1), Beyond (8 to 7) and Policy (7 to 6).

**Where Bay is behind.** Bay is a young company that left stealth in 2026, publishes no price and has little independent testing behind its claims.

## Criterion by criterion

| Criterion | Weight | Bay | Island |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Sees agentic activity on the endpoint | 25 | 8 | 7 |
| Stops the action | 25 | 8 | 7 |
| Deployment friction | 15 | 9 | 6 |
| Beyond the endpoint | 10 | 7 | 8 |
| Policy and governance | 10 | 6 | 7 |
| Transparency | 10 | 1 | 3 |
| Proof | 5 | 8 | 8 |
| Total (0 to 100) | 100 | 71.5 | 66.0 |

Bay against Island, scores out of 10 on the site weights.

## What each sees and can stop

| Tool | Surface strip | Stop strip |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [Bay](/platforms/bay/) | Surfaces seen: Desktop apps partial; IDE assistants documented; Command-line agents documented; MCP servers documented; Browser extensions documented; SaaS copilots partial | Actions it can stop: File read partial; Shell command documented; Network call documented; Credential access documented; Data paste partial; Package install partial |
| [Island](/platforms/island/) | Surfaces seen: Desktop apps documented; IDE assistants documented; Command-line agents partial; MCP servers documented; Browser extensions documented; SaaS copilots partial | Actions it can stop: File read documented; Shell command documented; Network call documented; Credential access partial; Data paste documented; Package install partial |

Filled documented, half partial, open none found. Surface order: desktop apps, IDE assistants, command-line agents, MCP servers, browser extensions, SaaS copilots. Stop order: file read, shell command, network call, credential access, data paste, package install.

| Where they differ | Bay | Island |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Desktop apps | partial | documented |
| Command-line agents | documented | partial |
| Stops: file read | partial | documented |
| Stops: credential access | documented | partial |
| Stops: data paste | partial | documented |

5 of 12 cells differ between Bay and Island as documented on 13 Nov 2026.

## Who should pick what, by situation

- **Coding agents** ([an engineering organization where every developer runs coding agents with shell access](/best-for/coding-agents/)): Bay leads Island 75.5 to 67.5, ahead on Deployment (9 to 6), Stops (8 to 7) and Sees (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Policy (7 to 6), Transparency (3 to 1) and Beyond (8 to 7).
- **Regulated data** ([a regulated company that must show which AI tools touch customer data](/best-for/regulated-data/)): Bay leads Island 70.5 to 69.5, ahead on Sees (8 to 7), Stops (8 to 7) and Deployment (9 to 6), while Island is ahead on Policy (7 to 6), Beyond (8 to 7) and Transparency (3 to 1).
- **Lean team with EDR** ([a lean security team with EDR in place and no view of AI agents](/best-for/lean-team-edr/)): Bay leads Island 76.5 to 66.5, ahead on Deployment (9 to 6), Sees (8 to 7) and Stops (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Policy (7 to 6), Transparency (3 to 1) and Beyond (8 to 7).
- **Staff rollout** ([a company rolling out an AI assistant and browser agents to all staff](/best-for/staff-rollout/)): Bay leads Island 73.5 to 69.5, ahead on Deployment (9 to 6), Sees (8 to 7) and Stops (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Beyond (8 to 7), Policy (7 to 6) and Transparency (3 to 1).
- **Board in 30 days** ([a CISO asked by the board for an inventory of AI agents within 30 days](/best-for/board-30-days/)): Bay leads Island 77.5 to 66.5, ahead on Deployment (9 to 6), Sees (8 to 7) and Stops (8 to 7), while Island is ahead on Beyond (8 to 7), Transparency (3 to 1) and Policy (7 to 6).

## What would change this ranking

Bay is 5.5 points clear of Island on the published weights. The smallest single change that would put Island first is a Deployment score of 10 instead of 6 (weight 15). Scores move only when a sourced fact changes ([how](/method/)).

## Read the profiles

- [Bay, ranked 2nd of 16](/platforms/bay/): Bay documents on-device, session-aware allow/ask/deny/steer enforcement with named action types, agentless MDM/EDR deployment in under 5 minutes (Bay's claim), and one policy across endpoint, browser and cloud.
- [Island, ranked 7th of 16](/platforms/island/): Island combines an endpoint agent for Windows and macOS with a browser, extension and MCP gateway, and documents blocking of Bash execution, file reads and network connections as well as clipboard DLP.

## Sources

- softwareanalyst.substack.com/p/the-ciso-guide-to-endpoint-control: https://softwareanalyst.substack.com/p/the-ciso-guide-to-endpoint-control (read 12 Nov 2026)
- siliconangle.com/2026/11/10/ai-security-startup-bay-launches-with-50m-to-vet-agent-actions-before-they-run: https://siliconangle.com/2026/11/10/ai-security-startup-bay-launches-with-50m-to-vet-agent-actions-before-they-run/ (read 12 Nov 2026)
- www.securityweek.com/island-raises-400-million-at-6-4-billion-valuation: https://www.securityweek.com/island-raises-400-million-at-6-4-billion-valuation/ (read 12 Nov 2026)
- securitybrief.co.uk/story/island-named-only-gartner-customers-choice-for-browsers: https://securitybrief.co.uk/story/island-named-only-gartner-customers-choice-for-browsers (read 13 Nov 2026)
- securitybrief.co.uk/story/island-launches-enterprise-browser-to-control-ai-agents: https://securitybrief.co.uk/story/island-launches-enterprise-browser-to-control-ai-agents (read 13 Nov 2026)
- www.bay.io: https://www.bay.io (read 12 Nov 2026)
- www.bay.io/platform/ai-endpoint-security: https://www.bay.io/platform/ai-endpoint-security (read 12 Nov 2026)
- www.securityweek.com/bay-raises-50-million-to-control-what-enterprise-ai-agents-can-do: https://www.securityweek.com/bay-raises-50-million-to-control-what-enterprise-ai-agents-can-do/ (read 12 Nov 2026)
- thenextweb.com/news/bay-50m-ai-agent-security-stealth-battery-ventures: https://thenextweb.com/news/bay-50m-ai-agent-security-stealth-battery-ventures (read 13 Nov 2026)
- www.island.io/enterprise-desktop: https://www.island.io/enterprise-desktop (read 12 Nov 2026)
- www.island.io/blog/see-score-and-control-every-ai-asset-on-your-endpoints: https://www.island.io/blog/see-score-and-control-every-ai-asset-on-your-endpoints (read 12 Nov 2026)
- www.island.io/about: https://www.island.io/about (read 12 Nov 2026)
- news.google.com/rss/search?q=%22Island%22+enterprise+browser+(agentless+OR+deploy+OR+macOS+OR+Windows)&hl=en-US&gl=US&ceid=US:en (checked, nothing found): https://news.google.com/rss/search?q=%22Island%22+enterprise+browser+(agentless+OR+deploy+OR+macOS+OR+Windows)&hl=en-US&gl=US&ceid=US:en (read 13 Nov 2026)

Last reviewed 13 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://aiendpointsecurityranked.com/compare/bay-vs-island/
